Letters, War and Orcs
Part 1: Intro
Dear Reader,
At the time of writing the below blog post, The Rings of Power had just finished its second season, and discussion abounded on forums about the ‘morally grey’ portrayal of the orcs.They aren’t simply mindless monsters.They are shown having children and families, and their leader, Adar, while not wholly good in his means, does seem to have his people in his heart. They are rational beings. The controversy in this portrayal very predictably comes from people who see this as a modernization of Tolkien’s orcs: creatures who they believe should be mindless monsters and killing machines.
It is my contention that The Rings of Power’s decision to add depth to Tolkien’s orcs not only has precedent in the source material, but that it is also necessary to fully do justice to Sauron’s succession of Morgoth while also happening to reflect Tolkien’s own sentiments on War and Evil that are evident in The Letters of Tolkien.
I was initially hesitant to post this on my blog, since I felt that the justification for the portrayal of the orcs in this manner would eventually become common knowledge, or perhaps even obvious due to how the show continued to play out in further seasons. Disappointingly, the discourse on this topic doesn’t seem to have evolved much at all since the end of season 2. Upon revisiting my writing now that season three is airing, I’ve decided that this piece absolutely deserves a place on my blog, especially since Amazon has doubled down and added in an original Orc character in its third season (we will see how that turns out). As of writing this intro, I have not yet watched the third season of Amazon’s The Rings of Power, yet I am as firmly as ever rooted in my stance that this was a correct decision in the portrayal of Tolkien's orcs and I am prepared to explain why – verbosely.
The Letters of JRR Tolkien is an assortment of posthumously published correspondences from JRR Tolkien, and is an invaluable resource in revealing Tolkien’s own inner thoughts surrounding his works. It is where my blog post begins.
Part 2: The Blog Post
I was reading through my copy of The Letters of JRR Tolkien and was struck with an interesting observation. The letters in question are “Letters” 64-72 which were written April 30, 1944 through May 31, 1944. All of these with one exception are between JRR Tolkien and his son, Christopher who was writing to his father about World War 2 and his experiences having just been drafted into the airforce. They paint a very interesting picture of father and son, one who fought in the First World War, the other now actively participating in the second, both of whom were not inclined to war. Tolkien talks to Christopher about their shared experience and how he chose to cope with the horror and evils he saw in the trenches by writing a story.
“I sense amongst all your pains (some merely physical) the desire to express your feeling about good, evil, fair, foul in some way: to rationalize it, and prevent it just festering. In my case it generated Morgoth and the History of the Gnomes [The Elves]. Lots of the early parts of which (and the languages) - discarded or absorbed - were done in grimy canteens, at lectures in cold fogs, in huts full of blasphemy and smut, or by candle light in bell-tents, even some down in dugouts under shell fire” - Letter 64 (April 30, 1944)
Tolkien used his writing as a way of making sense of the things he saw and felt as he endured his time serving during the First World War. It’s well known that he was against using his work as an ‘allegory’ (which is a very loaded word to bring up around Tolkien fans) but when writing to his son and attempting to help him make sense of his own turn at war, he was more than willing to draw analogies using his works and creations. A couple quotes stood out to me in particular:
“The utter stupid waste of war, not only material but moral and spiritual, is so staggering to those who have to endure it. And always was (despite the poets), and always will be (despite the propagandists) - not of course that it has not is and will be necessary to face it in an evil world.” - Letter 64
Tolkien’s feelings on War could not be laid bare more clearly. War is not only destructive but ‘wasteful, its cost is felt as a people, and as a culture, and yet it is still an inevitability in the messed up world he perceived.
“For we are attempting to conquer Sauron with the Ring. And we shall (it seems) succeed. But the penalty is, as you will know, to breed new Saurons, and slowly turn Men and Elves into Orcs.” - Letter 66 (May 6, 1944)
Sauron, used as an archetype, or as an inevitability when power and control are concerned.
“Not that in real life things are as clear cut as in a story, and we started out with a great many Orcs on our side..... Well, there you are: a hobbit amongst the Urukhai. Keep up your hobbitry in heart, and think that all stories feel like that when you are in them. You are inside a very great story!” - Letter 66 (May 6, 1944)
“Yes, I think the orcs as real a creation as anything in 'realistic' fiction ... only in real life they are on both sides, of course. For 'romance' has grown out of 'allegory', and its wars are still derived from the 'inner war' of allegory in which good is on one side and various modes of badness on the other. In real (exterior) life men are on both sides: which means a motley alliance of orcs, beasts, demons, plain naturally honest men, and angels.” - Letter 71 (May 25, 1944)
An acknowledgment of the archetypal concept of Orcs being able to represent corrupted souls on any side of a conflict.
“The more men think of human beings as machines that tick over when you turn certain handles, the more they'll rely on that sort of rot. And the worse the less mechanical humans will suffer. [...] speed in your service [war], where men are more nearly reduced to the serfs of machinery than in any other, do need to be made into bright quick ready slaves. Alas! that you of all folk should ever have landed yourself in the Urukhai. [...] And I expect you'd have found Ocrdom anywhere. This is War.” - Letter 66
To me, these quotes very much paint a picture of a man who saw war as the real evil of our own ‘story’, and how it bred Orcs out of people who otherwise would have never done evil. He saw it as an evil force that exerted its influence monotonously and inevitably over those it came into contact with, harming us as individuals spiritually at the same time as it worked to harm our culture and force it further into industry - turning men into slave-like machines.
Tolkien admits at several points in these letters that for the sake of The Lord of the Rings, the archetypal Orc had to be simplified. People often take this stance to mean that he wrote the orcs as completely irredeemable monsters, but I think it’s clear from these quotes that he means the simplification is to only put them on one side of the conflict.
As a quick aside, at the same time that JRR Tolkien was writing to Christopher about coping with and making sense of war, he is also interspersing updates on his progress on writing the chapters from “The Passage of the Marshes” up to “The Choices of Master Samwise” in what would eventually become The Two Towers. Now that these chapters have been finished and are well known, I can’t help but think of a few places where the sentiment from these letters seems to be coming through.
“It was Sam's first view of a battle of Men against Men, and he did not like it much. He was glad that he could not see the dead face. He wondered what the man's name was and where he came from; and if he was really evil of heart, or what lies or threats had led him on the long march from his home; and if he would rather have stayed there in peace” - The Two Towers
Many will likely remember this as a favorite quote from the Peter Jackson movie trilogy, where Sam’s thoughts are instead delivered as a line by Faramir. It wonderfully reflects the sentiment of all the professor seems to be trying to tell Christopher across these letters related to war, not losing yourself and remaining good at heart. It’s clear from the letters I was reading that thoughts like this were weighing on his mind: rightfully so with a son (and everyone else’s sons) going off to fight in the second world war.
In these same chapters, there is to my knowledge, one of the only places in The Lord of the Rings that we get meaningful and informative dialogue between orc characters: the conversation between two orcs: Shagrat and Gorbag that Sam overhears after they have caught Frodo after Shelob’s lair.
"'But I don't enquire how it's done. Safest not to. Grr! Those Nazgûl give me the creeps. And they skin the body off you as soon as look at you, and leave you all cold in the dark on the other side. But He likes 'em; they're His favourites nowadays, so it's no use grumbling. I tell you, it's no game serving down in the city.’ ‘You should try being up here with Shelob for company,' said Shagrat. ‘I'd like to try somewhere where there's none of 'em. But the war's on now, and when that's over things may be easier.' 'It's going well, they say.' 'They would,' grunted Gorbag. 'We'll see. But anyway, if it does go well, there should be a lot more room. What d'you say? - if we get a chance, you and me'll slip off and set up somewhere on our own with a few trusty lads, somewhere where there's good loot nice and handy, and no big bosses.’ 'Ah!' said Shagrat. 'Like old times.' 'Yes,' said Gorbag. 'But don't count on it. I'm not easy in my mind. As I said, the Big Bosses, ay,' his voice sank almost to a whisper, 'ay, even the Biggest, can make mistakes. Something nearly slipped, you say. I say, something has slipped. And we've got to look out. Always the poor Uruks to put slips right, and small thanks.’” - The Choices of Master Samwise, The Two Towers
They’re discussing their lives outside the war and what they would do if they didn’t have masters holding sticks over their heads. They have all the charm of two corporate office workers feeling unappreciated at their job and hating their bosses. This passage has always stood out to me in its humanization of the orcs. It doesn’t necessarily make me sympathize with them: they still want to pillage and harm others even once they’re free, but it does bring to light the fact that the orcs do think about being free. That they do have minds that go beyond being slaves of war and have an actual concept of a desired community: even if it’s still based on pillaging and raiding. The sentiment that even orcs were capable of thinking freely and might desire to break away from war temporarily couldn’t help but bleed through in The Lord of the Rings - in the very chapters Tolkien was writing when he was talking to his son deeply about these concepts in real-life wars.
We must remember that the orcs in the first age were created and enslaved by Morgoth, and that the orcs of the third age were re-enslaved by Sauron. They have been twisted by the dark magic and sentiment of Morgoth and taught by him and Sauron across generations to take pleasure in war against the free peoples of Middle earth - of whom they are no longer a part. Their tragedy is that they have been forced into evil for so long, that as a people they have entirely forgotten what being ‘good’ is. But even still, they could not be stripped entirely of their free will (that is outside the power of Morgoth or Sauron) and it has only been suppressed.
“And deep in their dark hearts the Orcs loathed the Master whom they served in fear, the maker only of their misery. This it may be was the vilest deed of Melkor, and the most hateful to Ilúvatar [God].” - The Silmarillion
Shagrat and Gorbag: the orcs that bring these deeper thoughts about the legendarium to mind are orcs that I can see being descended from the followers of Adar. Adar’s orcs are not good by any means. Anyone who says that The Rings of Power is trying to make them seem ‘good’ hasn’t watched the show. They pillage, they burn, they take joy in causing suffering, and in their freedom they decided it would be best if they devastated an entire ecosystem to make their home. Upon watching first season, one of my very first impressions was just how terrifying the Orcs were. And yet they still have their free will. They still have a society and a desire for a home. They are led by their own hero: Adar. They are victims of their former master and have lost sight of the light. We cannot excuse their deeds, and it may very well be possible that they have been twisted beyond healing or redemption.
“The Wise in the Elder Days taught always that the Orcs were not ‘made’ by Melkor, and therefore were not in their origin evil. They might have become irredeemable (at least by Elves and Men), but they remained within the Law. That is, that though of necessity, being the fingers of the hand of Morgoth, they must be fought with the utmost severity, they must not be dealt with in their own terms of cruelty and treachery. Captives must not be tormented, not even to discover information for the defence of the homes of Elves and Men. If any Orcs surrendered and asked for mercy, they must be granted it, even at a cost. This was the teaching of the Wise, though in the horror of the War it was not always heeded.” - Morgoth’s Ring
The Orcs are a tragedy brought about by Morgoth and perpetuated by Sauron. The show has chosen to portray Adar as a bit of a tragic and failed hero for the orcs: ultimately betrayed and beaten by Sauron in season two, who then re-enslaves the orcs as tools of war and who will ultimately continue to suppress and control their minds for his own designs. I would like to recall what happens to the Orcs in the moment when Frodo claims The One Ring at the crack of doom. Moments before its destruction and Sauron’s demise we are told:
“From all his [Sauron’s] policies and webs of fear and treachery, from all his stratagems and wars his mind shook free; and throughout his realm a tremor ran, his slaves quailed, and his armies halted, and his captains, suddenly steerless, bereft of will, wavered and despaired. For they were forgotten. The whole mind and purpose of the Power that wielded them was now bent with overwhelming force upon the Mountain” - The Return of the King
The second age is the backdrop to the story of The Lord of the Rings. It was written by Tolkien as a mythical tapestry that paints the wall behind it rather than as a completed narrative. Amazon needs to fill in many gaps if their goal is to tell the second age as an actual story with fleshed out characters. They have taken a very roundabout way of doing so and have fumbled in a few places, but their approach to the orcs is not one of them. They have chosen to fill in the story with an interpretation of the orcs that shows them as lost, twisted creatures who have nonetheless clung to a semblance of free will and society. Doing so is necessary for us to understand the full depths of Sauron’s evil in being willing and able to wrest their entire race under his control.
As a fan of Tolkien’s deeper legendarium, the portrayal of the orcs, and their seemingly inevitable enslavement by Sauron has been one of my favorite parts of the show. It gave us time to look at the story from another perspective: a perspective that looks at the orcs as realistic creations beyond the one dimensional caricatures they’ve been cast into by previous adaptations. And on top of that, the tragic completion of Adar’s character arc makes the deeds of Sauron in his pursuit for complete control hit that much harder.



Comments